Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles: Which Roofing Material Is Right for You?

When the time comes to replace your roof, one of the biggest choices you’ll face is metal roofing vs asphalt shingles. Asphalt shingles have long been the go-to roofing option in the United States, but metal roofs are becoming more popular as homeowners learn about their long-term performance benefits.

If you’re a homeowner, you might be wondering if metal is worth the extra upfront investment, or if you should stick with the traditional shingle roof you’re more familiar with. If you’re a contractor, you’re probably evaluating which material will provide the best long-term value for your clients and how to present the pros and cons clearly.

This blog will give you a detailed comparison of metal roofs vs shingle roofs, including cost, durability, energy efficiency, sustainability, and curb appeal. By the end, you’ll have a clearer idea of which roofing material is the better fit for your project or your customer’s needs.

Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles: Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Metal Roofing	Asphalt Shingles
Lifespan	40-70 years	15-25 years
Maintenance	Minimal	Requires regular upkeep and repairs
Durability	Resistant to snow, hail, wind, fire, and UV damage	Prone to cracking, curling, and granule loss
Style Options	Modern panels, ribbed, shingles that mimic slate/tile	Standard look with limited variety
Energy Effiecieny	Reflects heat, lowers cooling bills	Absorbs heat, higher cooling bills
Sustainability	Recyclable, often made with recycled materials	Petroleum-based, ends up in landfills
Cost (installed)	$8-14 per sq. ft (high upfront cost)	$4–$8 per sq. ft. (lower upfront)
Total Value	Higher ROI over lifespan	Lower upfront but more frequent replacements

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material across the U.S. They are manufactured using a fiberglass mat that is coated in asphalt for waterproofing, then finished with mineral granules for protection and color. Shingles come in three main types: 3-tab shingles(the most economical), architectural or dimensional shingles (thicker, with a layered appearance), and luxury shingles (designed to mimic slate or cedar shakes).

One of the biggest appeals of shingles is their affordability and availability. They are stocked by most suppliers, and installation is straightforward, which keeps labor costs down. For homeowners, asphalt shingles represent a familiar and budget-conscious choice.

However, the drawbacks of shingles show up over time. A shingle roof typically lasts 15–25 years, depending on weather conditions and upkeep. They are prone to curling, cracking, or blowing off in strong winds. In hot climates, shingles can warp or lose granules more quickly. While they can be patched and repaired, the overall maintenance needs add up.

Pros of Asphalt Shingles:

• Lower upfront cost than metal roofing
  
• Easy and fast installation for contractors
  
• Wide availability and variety of colors
  
• Familiar look that suits most neighborhoods

Cons of Asphalt Shingles:

• Shorter lifespan (15–25 years on average)
  
• Susceptible to wind, hail, and UV damage
  
• Can trap heat, raising energy bills in warm climates
  
• Made primarily from petroleum-based materials, making them less eco-friendly

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing comes in a variety of forms: standing seam panels, corrugated or ribbed panels, and even metal shingles that resemble tile or slate. Most residential metal roofs are made from steel or aluminum, though copper and zinc are also options at the premium end of the spectrum.

Modern metal roofing is designed to be durable, energy-efficient, and attractive. It can be finished with protective coatings such as galvalume or painted with high-performance finishes that resist fading and corrosion. Metal roofs are also highly customizable in terms of style and color, giving homeowners options that range from sleek and modern to rustic and traditional.

Perhaps the most compelling reason homeowners and contractors consider metal is its longevity. A properly installed metal roof can last 40–70 years, far outpacing asphalt shingles. This long service life makes it a strong investment, particularly for those planning to stay in their home long-term.

Advantages of Metal Roofing:

• Lifespan of 40–70 years (often double or triple asphalt shingles)
  
• Excellent durability against wind, fire, hail, and snow
  
• Energy efficiency: reflects solar heat, reducing cooling costs by 10–25%
  
• Sustainable: often made from recycled materials and fully recyclable at end of life
  
• Low maintenance compared to shingles
  

Potential Drawbacks:

• Higher upfront investment than asphalt shingles
  
• Requires skilled installation for best performance
  
• Can be noisier during rain or hail (though underlayment reduces this significantly)

Other FAQs: Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles

Do Metal Roofs Leak More Than Shingles?

No. In fact, properly installed metal roofs are less likely to leak than asphalt shingles. Shingle roofs can develop leaks as they age, especially when shingles crack, curl, or blow off in storms. Metal roofing panels are designed with interlocking seams and protective coatings that provide superior water resistance.

Is it Cheaper to Have Metal Roofs or Shingles?

Upfront, asphalt shingles are the cheaper option. However, the long-term story is different. Because shingles usually last only 15–25 years, homeowners may need two or even three shingle roof replacements during the lifespan of one metal roof, which can last 40–70 years. Add in lower maintenance and energy savings, and a metal roof vs shingle roof comparison often shows metal as the more cost-effective choice over time.

What are the pros and cons of putting a metal roof over shingles?

The main benefit is saving money and time since you skip tearing off the old shingles. The downside is that if the shingles are in bad shape, problems may get trapped underneath. Always check local codes before deciding.

Which Roofing Material Is Right for You?

Deciding between metal roofing vs asphalt shingles ultimately comes down to priorities.

• If affordability and familiarity are your main concerns, asphalt shingles may be the right choice. They are quick to install, readily available, and provide a functional solution for 15–25 years.
  
• If long-term value, durability, and sustainability matter more, metal roofing is the superior option. While the initial cost is higher, the payoff in longevity, energy savings, and reduced maintenance makes it a worthwhile investment.

Contractors should guide their customers through this decision by presenting not just the upfront cost, but the lifetime performance and total cost of ownership of each material.

Metal Panels for Sale

While asphalt shingles remain the most familiar option, the advantages of metal roofing make it a strong contender for today’s homeowners. Its durability, energy efficiency, sustainability, and modern style options provide long-term benefits that shingles simply can’t match.

At Wagler Steel, we manufacture high-quality metal roofing panels designed to serve both residential and commercial projects. Whether you’re a homeowner weighing your first roof replacement or a contractor seeking durable solutions for clients, our team can help you evaluate the best fit.

Ready to learn more about our metal roofing options? Contact us today to get expert advice and discover the roofing system that will best serve your home or business for decades.